Request a demo
Back to Blog

How to adopt more positive behaviors through negative reinforcement

July 27, 2022 - 10 min read

smiling-business-team-standing-during-meeting-negative-reinforcement

Jump to section

What is negative reinforcement and how does it work?

4 examples of negative reinforcement

What is the difference between negative reinforcement and punishment?

Negative reinforcement versus positive reinforcement

When to use negative reinforcement

Benefits of using negative reinforcement

The bottom line

Think back to a day at the beach you spent at the beach. The waves crashing on the shore, salt seeping down from the air onto your tongue, the sunshine beating down, nice and hot. And the next thing you know, you’re slathering aloe vera onto an itchy sunburn, just like your mom warned you.

After that, you thought about sunscreen. When you go to the beach next time, you’ll dutifully remember to slather on heaps of sunscreen to avoid getting another burn. 

This scenario is an example of negative reinforcement. 

Many of us would automatically say that positive reinforcement, or being rewarded for good behavior, is the best way to encourage healthy habits to form. Research shows that, overall, positive reinforcement is often more effective, especially when accounting for the individual’s sense of agency, empathy, self-compassion, and ability to regulate and motivate themselves.

Child development and education research has yielded volumes on the variety of approaches that use one or the other form of reinforcement, often both. 

But in some situations and done correctly, negative reinforcement can be effective. And beneficial. Think about a toddler continuously reaching out to touch the flickering flame of a candle. Douse the flame and the dangerous behavior stops. Sometimes an action or behavior needs to stop — quickly. It all depends on the individual and the situation.

In the following article, we’ll look at the circumstances that favor negative reinforcement, although only for adults. We’ll leave the children to their own experts.

What is negative reinforcement and how does it work?

Have you ever heard of Pavlov's dog? Or Skinner’s rat? 

Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov explored responses to certain stimuli or triggers. Pavlov hypothesized that dogs would salivate when they saw food because they knew it would taste good. Over time, he observed that the dogs would associate his approaching footsteps with food and began to salivate at that, too.

In the second case, American psychologist B.F. Skinner also studied behavioral responses, though his methods differed. Skinner put a rat in a box and exposed it to small electric shocks. The shocks would stop if the rat hit a lever inside the box. The rats learned to seek out the lever to stop the pain. 

Both Pavlov and Skinner were interested in what is known today as operant conditioning or positive and negative reinforcement. 

Humans respond in similar ways. 

Negative reinforcement refers to a reaction to an event during which something is removed, terminated, reduced, or postponed. This ensures that the adverse behavior doesn’t continue — like forgetting to wear sunscreen.

Changing your behavior is tough, but at BetterUp, our coaches are here to provide the perspective and accountability you need to keep going. They can help you think through your approach to positive and negative reinforcement with your teams, families, and other relationships, too. If you’re willing to put in the work, we’ll support you every step of the way. 

New call-to-action

4 examples of negative reinforcement

Aversive stimuli make us uncomfortable. When we perform a particular behavior to avoid this feeling, our brains see that action as a reward, and we’re more likely to do it again.

We respond to negative reinforcement every day, even if we don’t realize it. Below are some common examples of this:

  1. You clean up your dishes and put them away after eating a delicious snack to avoid your partner nagging you about the mess on the counter. 
  2. After getting stuck in a 2-hour traffic jam during the morning commute and getting an unpleasant warning from your manager, the next morning, you decide to head to work sooner to avoid rush-hour traffic and being late. 
  3. You suffer through a long and unpleasant dental cleaning (and lecture). As soon as you’re back home, you make a decision to commit to an evening flossing habit and only drink juice through a straw to avoid such a painful experience in the future. 
  4. You set your alarm to wake up and it’s very annoying. You hit the snooze button to silence the noise.

morning-shot-of-a-person-lying-in-bed-negative-reinforcement

What is the difference between negative reinforcement and punishment?

It’s easy to mix up negative reinforcement and negative punishment, but they’re not the same. 

Punishment is all about weakening or discouraging a behavior. For example, let’s say that Jack and Jill are constantly bickering, as siblings do. Jill calls her brother names, so her parents take away her favorite doll. Taking Jill's toy deters her bad behavior. Or does it?

Punishment adds a condition by either giving or taking something away, like Jill’s toy. In contrast, negative reinforcement would remove something — like a stimulus. Negative reinforcement would send little brother Jack out of the room after Jill treated him with patience and kindness.

The stimulus (annoying sibling) removed would reinforce the positive behavior (kindness). Punishment teaches you what not to do, and negative reinforcement teaches you what you should do. 

mature-man-talking-to-colleagues-in-modern-office-negative-reinforcement

Negative reinforcement versus positive reinforcement

Despite how it sounds, negative reinforcement isn’t the opposite of positive reinforcement. 

Both types of reinforcement aim to promote positive behavior. 

Negative reinforcement relies on unpleasant stimuli, like your mom lecturing you about not doing your chores; positive reinforcement focuses on agreeable stimuli. If a child completes their homework and can watch an hour of their favorite TV show, it positively reinforces the completion of homework. 

Both techniques are successful; it just depends on the method you choose.

When to use negative reinforcement

two-teenage-girls-comfort-their-friend-negative-reinforcement

Negative reinforcement is most effective when it occurs immediately. Positive reinforcement has proven more useful regarding long-term changes.

The frequency of reinforcement is important, but making adjustments depending on what motives or dissuades a person is too. 

Negative reinforcement can be an effective tool to help improve one’s personal and professional development

If you make a mistake at work, your boss likely reprimands you. But if you have to work late to double-check your work and fix the problem, you’re more likely to learn your lesson. Overcoming adversity and learning from your mistakes is a great way to drive your professional development and learn from the consequences of your actions.

Benefits of using negative reinforcement

Remember that negative reinforcement doesn’t encourage negative behavior. It’s just approaching an issue from a different angle. 

This has become a popular method, but why? 

  1. It’s simple.
  2. It works.  
  3. It doesn’t take long for an individual or animal to associate the source of reinforcement with the desired behavior. 
young-woman-smiling-looking-away-negative-reinforcement

The bottom line

The term “negative” can be misleading since it doesn't traditionally mean what most people think. Repetitiveness, or in other words, adhering to a schedule of reinforcement, and timing matter. These two aspects will ultimately decide whether a target behavior persists or not. 

At BetterUp, we believe that everyone can achieve positive transformation in their own way. Bringing together AI technology and behavioral science expertise, our coaches strive to help every individual unlock their greater potential, purpose, and passion. 

Our coaches are here to aid you in your growth by helping you balance a go-getter attitude and building sustainable habits that encourage hard work, self-directed learning, and cultivate leadership.

New call-to-action

Published July 27, 2022

Maggie Wooll

Managing Editor

Read Next

Coaching
9 min read | June 10, 2021

Member story: A copilot for the road ahead

Learn how this BetterUp member worked with his Coach to shape his days, unearth goals, and think about the road ahead to chart his course for the future. Read More
Diversity & Inclusion
8 min read | April 6, 2021

Defining the gender gap in coaching: what it is and how to fix it

BetterUp Labs set out to understand how access to personalized support and leadership development through coaching may be relevant to the broader gender gap. Equal access to... Read More
Coaching
8 min read | July 14, 2021

What I didn't know before working with a coach: The power of reflection

Coaches help us learn to see ourselves. Reflection is a powerful tool for self-awareness and growth, leading to professional success and life satisfaction. Read More
Coaching
11 min read | September 9, 2021

Organizational coaching: Everything you wanted to know but were afraid to ask

Organizational coaching targets systemic change within a company. Learn how it works, why it’s so important, and how to choose the best program. Read More
Coaching
17 min read | September 20, 2021

Virtual coaching: the benefits of coaching without constraints

Zoomed out? Here’s one reason to keep your camera on. Learn what to expect in a virtual coaching conversation and how to choose the best program. Read More
Well-being
20 min read | April 15, 2022

The best mental health podcasts to listen to any time

Mental health podcasts can teach, inspire, and reinforce healthy habits. Learn more about mental health podcasts and check out some of our favorites. Read More
Coaching
16 min read | November 24, 2021

The Great Resignation: It’s time to meet employees where they are

Resignation could mean giving up, but today’s job market is changing that. Learn how employers need to think about retention in the Great Resignation. Read More
Research & Insights
8 min read | January 12, 2022

Language analysis reveals how coaching has evolved over the last 3 years

As we start a new year, we used language analysis to look back at how professional coaching has changed over the past three years Read More
Research & Insights
8 min read | January 27, 2022

Managers and individual contributors take different approaches to coaching

We used natural language processing to see how and why coaching topics differ between managers and individual contributors Read More

Stay connected with BetterUp

Get our newsletter, event invites, plus product insights and research.